“Big. Old. Shocker.”
Indeed, this time last year, the six-time Tony winner was surprised to discover she was about to be a mom again. So were the fans who were excited to see her in the historic, all-black Broadway production of Shuffle Along and in her West End debut for Lady Day at Emerson’s Bar and Grill, which was set to open in London last summer, a production that earned her a Tony in 2014.
She had to take a maternity leave from Broadway (Shuffle closed) and the London show had to be postponed (she’ll head to the U.K. this summer for it) — but she said her husband, the actor Will Swenson, is the world’s biggest Denver Broncos fan, and well, when Von Miller was strip-sacking Cam Newton on his way to winning the game’s MVP in Levi’s Stadium last year, things got frisky in the McDonald-Swenson household.
The Broncos owe her a onesie.
It’s all worked out — and then some. McDonald took a quick break from her beloved stage to co-star in Disney’s new Beauty and the Beast, a live-action version of the classic 1991 animated film. Production for the fairy tale began last May at London’s Shepperton Studios. As with the animated version, the film tells the story of a prince who is placed under a curse. All of his servants are turned into random objects in his castle, as well.
McDonald portrays Madame Garderobe, an opera-singing lady-in-waiting who is in love with fashion and helps doll up Belle (Emma Watson). With this role, McDonald is doing in film what she’s managed to expertly do on Broadway for years.
From the start of her career, McDonald has successfully defied racial typecasting. Part of a military family, she was born in West Berlin and raised in Fresno, California. She’s starred in Broadway roles that were never intended for a black actress, and she’s one of the most successful stage actors of all time.
“My parents were the ones who — literally and figuratively — led me to theater as a way to channel a hyperactivity and energy that I had that was … becoming an issue,” said McDonald. “We found this outlet for me, it was a perfect fit. And they were very concerned and made sure that I never played any role that was any type of stereotyping.” McDonald said there were a couple of shows that she wanted to audition for that would have perhaps been demeaning. Her parents weren’t having it. “It became buried in my psyche,” she said, “so that for me, it was all about, ‘What role am I right for? What essence of the character am I right for?’ As opposed to, ‘Well, that’s a black person so I can play that.’ I just refused to be stereotyped.”
It’s worked out nicely for her. McDonald has wowed critics in roles like Carrie Pipperidge in the 1994 Lincoln Center revival of Rodgers & Hammerstein’s Carousel (she won a Tony for it) and Lizzie Curry in Lonny Price’s 2007 revival of 110 in the Shade — both roles that only white actresses have ever held. It’s impressive in an industry where job descriptions are spelled out by race and sex: “black woman in her 30s,” “blond 20-something woman,” and so on. McDonald has forced casting directors to actually see her.
“You don’t win every battle, that’s for sure. But you stick to your guns,” she said. “And that’s not to say I don’t want to play a character because they’re black. For me, it’s about what is the role? Is it something that I feel that I can connect to and can learn from and will challenge me? And is there something that I have enough of inside of me that will illuminate that role? That’s it. I just put no limitations, regardless of how aesthetically driven this society is. I try and listen to my gut.”
She’s part of a super successful sisterhood. McDonald’s Juilliard classmate, the two-time-Tony-winning Viola Davis, was awarded the best supporting actress Oscar last month for her role as Rose in Denzel Washington’s Fences, a portrayal that Davis also skillfully acted in the 2010 Broadway revival. About an hour before Davis’ category was even announced, McDonald semi-jokingly tweeted “did Viola get her Oscar yet?”
“Twenty five years ago, Viola and I we were in school together and we all knew then that she was the greatest thing that there had ever been. Viola … has not changed at all. It’s just the world is now awake, and sees that, and values that,” McDonald said. “She deserves it.”
As does McDonald. Her accomplishments are wildly impressive. She’s won an Emmy, two Grammys, five Outer Critics Circle Awards, and five Drama Desk Awards. She has four NAACP Image Awards nominations, and she’s the first person to win a Tony in all four acting categories. To be a part of the coveted and tiny fraternity known as EGOT (performers who have won an Emmy, a Grammy, an Oscar and a Tony) all she needs is an award from the academy. Only 12 people have earned all four awards. McDonald is pacing herself for whatever might be her big Hollywood moment — but her heart belongs to theater.
“Theater is my mother tongue, it’s my first language,” she said. “Anytime that I get on the stage — and this is something that I started to realize … when I was hospitalized for being suicidal — I feel the freest. I feel the most like myself. That sounds contradictory, when you’re out there most of the time playing other people, but I feel most at home, most alive, most beautiful, most all of that. The only other place I get that feeling is at home with my family. [The stage] has always been my savior. It’s a place to get the emotion out.”
McDonald’s is a voice that demands to be heard — and not just because she’s a lyric soprano who can hit a high F. Her Twitter handle — @AudraEqualityMc — reflects her views on marriage equality and she’s not shy about tweeting out opinions about the current political climate.
“I live in New York. There’s not one race, color, creed, anything, that is not represented here. So many of those people that I see and live among … can be disenfranchised by social injustices … immigrants or Muslims, or the LGBTQ community, or homeless children, or the homeless in general.” She said she sees the effects of injustice, and to raise her voice is the right thing to do. “I can’t be silent. And also … to quote Lin-Manuel Miranda: ‘Eyes on you.’ When we turn back around to look at the change that has occurred … who are we following? Who spoke up?’ There’s a complicity in silence. And I don’t want my kids to look back and say, ‘Wow, Mom was real quiet about all of that, and look at what ended up happening.’ ”
And even though she says being a mother is her most important role — McDonald has a 16-year-old daughter, Zoe Madeline, besides baby Sally James — there is a role that could properly woo her to the silver screen. It just hasn’t been written yet.
“There are women in history, and there’s one I’ve always thought about it. Wouldn’t it be neat to get a biopic about Marian Anderson? There’s so much to that life. That story that hasn’t been told,” she said. “That would marry my love of singing with a figure in time … someone who broke down all kinds of doors and … in her own quiet way … refused to be seen for anything but the artist she was. She let her talent do the talking.” McDonald has no idea if such a project will ever happen. “But if it does, I hope that I would be ready for it.”
Chances are good that she absolutely will be.